After debuting in 2011 Fitchett showed up infrequently before earning himself a regular roster spot in 2015 when he started teaming with Davey Vega. Together they have the record for the most cumulative days as tag team champions and with a total of three reigns they are just one away from tying the record of most reigns in AAW history. While mostly competing as a tag team wrestler for the last five years, Fitchett is a very capable singles wrestler and would often compete in tag matches one month and then a singles match the next month. He has had high profile singles matches with competitors such as Zack Sabre Jr, Chris Hero & Matt Riddle and even has two singles victories over ACH as well as a win over Drew Gulak in an incredible match from 2016 that is still talked about today. After separating from Vega in the Winter of 2020, Fitchett has seen a great deal of success winning the 2021 Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament and subsequently besting Fred Yehi at the Windy City Classic XVI for the AAW Heavyweight Championship.